Buying Gear?  Click Here
Buying gear? Please use these links to help 14ers.com:

More info...

Other ways to help...
 Peak(s):  Mt. Wilson  -  14,246 feet
El Diente Peak  -  14,159 feet
Wilson Peak  -  14,017 feet
 Post Date:  07/26/2010 Modified: 07/27/2010
 Date Climbed:   07/17/2010
 Posted By:  bergsteigen

 The perfect storm   


Mt Wilson - El Diente Traverse & Wilson Peak


Loose Rock Scramblers: Darrin (kansas), John, KeithK and me

Day 1: El Diente to Mt Wilson via the traverse
Ascent Route: North Buttress (VERY loose rock - potentially dangerous if there is a group above you)
Descent Route: North Slopes (not exactly NE ridge)
Mileage: 6.94
Elevation Gain: 3,444'

Facing a return to the longest day of 14ers I ever experienced... The Wilson - El Diente traverse is a big tough day. The scrambling begins early, and never really ends. Even with a fast group, 12 hours is normal. I've done 18 on a bad weather/conditions day. I hoped for better the second time around. I wanted nothing to do with the standard north gully route from last time. The north buttress route "claimed" to be on more solid rock. I guess if you compare horrendously loose rock to horribly loose rock, then that statement would be true. The north buttress route is marginally more *solid* than the standard gully. Proceed with caution, and bring your A-game. Novices need not apply.

We started early, and had kept our options open for which north route we would take. Not liking the melted out snow, we proceeded over to the Buttress route, loosing a bit of time in this change of plans. There had been some worry over route finding in the dark, but as first light was eeking over the Wilson-Gladstone ridge, we could see the start of the route easily enough. Once over the initial stages, the route proved to be rather solid and almost fun.

Image
Beginning of Buttress - fairly solid rocks (flowers = solid)

Image
Sunrise over Navaho Lake and Dolores Peak



The middle section of the route follows the ridge line more closely, and become loose. Darrin managed to move a gigantic boulder by stepping on an adjacent smaller rock. This got my heart racing, as I was below the boulder's destruction path. But it did serve as a reminder to be careful, and to TRUST NOTHING.

In this area, a group that started a bit after us, passed by on their way up the route. Chatting with a few in the group, I noted a glaring lack of experience in the members. Some only had a few 14ers climbed, and all easy ones. One talked about rafting/kayaking, as being his main sport. This would very soon become an issue, as they passed above us.

Image
Middle Part of Buttress - Rocks are becoming more loose


A peaceful moment - Photo credit: Darrin
Image
The rubble pile continues - no more flowers


The loose rocks abound now - Photo credit: Darrin

Coming around the feature in the next photo - Photo Credit: Darrin


Once over the mini knife edge and around a kind of saddle, the group above us let loose a shower of rocks down the slab region. I say shower, since it wasn't 3 rocks, it was probably a couple hundred or so. Nor was it a one time occurrence, it continued for 15 minutes. This shower fanned out over the entire slab region. If any of our party had been on the slabs, there would have been NO PROTECTION from the falling rocks. It would have been Russian Roulette to see who would be hit. Therefore, we hid under the only protection we had for about 30 minutes, or until we *hoped* that the group above us was off the peak and away from us. The story as I heard it back in camp, was that one in the upper party had stopped to rest on a pile of loose rocks. When he started to move upwards, or off this pile of rocks, it let go, endangering anyone in their group below them.

Image
The slabs - Avoid these if possible!!!


Of course, once we got near the slabs, we realized that the crux for us would be to actually get onto them. This is a class 4 section, if there ever was one. Both Darrin and I utilized climbing skills to cross this section, but neither of us was too comfortable. Neither John nor Keith wanted any part of the sketchy moves we had to perform to get across, and so headed up further. John nearly got cliffed out, but managed a tricky/sketchy traverse over to Darrin and I. Meanwhile Keith remained glued to where he was. He ended up deciding to find a better route to the summit. A small gully feature above him, and to the right of my (uploaded) photo #5. Keith says it didn't get above class 3, and he summitted before us.


What Darrin saw, having crossed onto the slabs - Photo credit: Darrin

Me making my way across - Photo credit: Darrin
Image
Keith not liking his options - found a better route to the summit


Once beyond this section, we ascended quickly, and I even missed the crux (as defined by the route author) at the chimneys. I was at the exit chimney at the summit ridge when I asked where the crux was.

Image
"The crux" - I didn't even realize it was the crux


Once on the summit, it was a giant relief. The traverse would be easy as compared to that sketchy loose ascent! Or at least that is what I remembered from my last trip across the traverse. We took a long break, to try and repair the frayed nerves. Since while the traverse is the easiest part of the day, it is also loose and very exposed in places.


A happy Keith! - Photo credit: Keith's camera

Image
Wilson Peak, Gladstone, Mt Wilson


The first section of the traverse went quickly enough, and we circumvented the organ pipes and the gendarmes. Ascending to the ridge afterwards proved to be more loose than I remember. But the upper ridge was wide enough to make quick work over the the ridge crux.

Image
The ridge to Mt Wilson

Image
Organ Pipes from above

Image
Traversing the first part


A look back to El Diente

Just hangin' - Photo credit: Darrin
Image
The first ridge walk over to the crux section


Photo Credit: Darrin

We took a quick break at the crux to examine our options. Last time I went directly up the center gully feature. But this time, we found the rock to the right of it, to be more solid and easier to get up.

Image
The crux - We went up the center, but finished on the more solid right section


From there, the narrow section was a bit of a surprise. The last time I had done the traverse, I didn't really remember this section, I just plowed through it. This time, I noted the exposure and so did everyone in our group (Note no photos!). We passed through it quickly, as the clouds to our south looked wet, while those to the north of the ridge were barely there. We stopped at the saddle before Mt Wilson to consider the weather and wait for everyone to catch up. We had to decide to make a run for it, or to bail, depending on what the cloud above Mt Wilson did. Thankfully it held off any rain for our summit bid.

Image
Mt Wilson summit ridge, looking scarier than it was

Image
El Diente and the traverse

Image

A not so happy Keith - Photo credit: Keith's camera

Happy to be descending Mt Wilson - Photo credit: Darrin

The descent off the peak was less than ideal. Snow/ice blocked the path to the ridge proper descent, so we slid down the loose gully back down to the nice trail below.

Image
Snow hampered our best descent options, so we just went down


14 hours later, we made it back to camp. Warning all those in our path about the loose nature of the North Buttress. It is also important to point out that my viewpoint on these peaks has changed from the first time I climbed them. I experienced different things, saw a different traverse. The first time I did these peaks, these were the hardest I had done, and I did them in very challenging conditions. Because of this, the traverse was easier. So I feel it is important to point this out, as you read TR's, gleaning information for your own trips. Some people will find certain routes easier (or harder) than others, depending on their own experiences and weather conditions.





Day 2: Wilson Peak
Route: SW Ridge
Mileage: 6.6
Elevation Gain: 2,813'

By comparison, Wilson Peak is a fairly easy day. We strolled up to the Rock of Ages Saddle to take a nice break and watch the sun rise.

Image
Alpenglow

Image
Alpenglow El Diente

Image
Wilson Peak - Rock of Ages saddle

Image
Gladstone

Image
El Diente shadows

Image

Once past the first saddle, the rocks get looser and helmets were donned by some. Around the corner of the second saddle, we were faced with some exciting traversing scrambling. But after the initial difficulties, the trail is pretty good to the false summit.

Image
The first part of the traverse over to the peak


Viewing the final summit crux pitch is fairly intimidating, until you get closer. Once upon it, the angle is much more relaxed, and fairly solid scrambling to the summit ensues. The second pitch up on the south side is more loose, and exposed, so we all tread carefully here.

Image
The peak crux

Image
Keith coming up the crux


Darrin going up (Must be solid - there's flowers) - Photo Credit: Keith

We take some time on the summit to enjoy the views. Once down, it will be a slog backpacking out. So here is our enjoyment for the day.
Image
Darrin approaching the summit

Image
Happy to be on the summit!


Descending the summit - Photo Credit: Keith
Image
Going Down

Image
A happy stream


My Photo Album from the weekend

Like a Phoenix rising from the ashes: Chicago Basin July 20-23: TR to come soon



Thumbnails for uploaded photos (click to open slideshow):
 


  • Comments or Questions
Nelson


Photography     2010-07-26 19:43:06
Outstanding photo quality! What kind of camera did you use?

Nelson


KeithK


To the point...     2010-07-27 12:38:17
Thanks for this trip, it really was a major accomplishment to find the summits of those peaks, and I can't be more thankful for the group that I was priveleged to be a part of. You guys really kept me alive, and I don't think that's an overstatement. El Diente's N. Buttress should really be taken seriously; I think the standard route should be from Kilpacker, including the traverse and descent of Mt. Wilson. If you do climb the buttress route, it's the opposite of Maroon Peak. Don't go left, go RIGHT at the slabs!


britdog


Congrats and Thank You     2010-07-26 20:54:27
Great job on what sounds like a very rough challenge. We are planning to attempt the Wilson Group this coming weekend, so your TR is of great interest and value. I had just read doggler's account of his traverse starting from Kilpacker and the extended rock hopping involved there, but it sounds better than the loose and dangerous conditions you described. I'd like to do the traverse, but all variables will have to be analyzed, especially in light of the events of today. I hope the survivors are not seriously injured.
Thanks again!


crossfitter


Good work     2010-07-26 21:28:23
Glad to see you guys did this one safely, especially after the recent accident there. Fantastic TR as always, Otina!


doggler


Congratulations     2010-07-27 07:40:34
on getting this group ”out of the way”. With all the loose rock and such up there, it's hard not to feel that way about the Wilsons.

With a camp at Navajo Lake, your group never really had the opportunity to do the Kilpacker/South Slopes, did you? I found the rock on that side to be not great but at least OK.


Presto


The Perspective on Repeats ...     2010-07-27 08:49:50
I hear you on your comments, Otina, of repeating climbs and traverses that you have not returned to for many years (or decades as has been the case for some of mine). I think my sense of awareness is more heightened on the repeats as I know I've already climbed the darned peak(s) before so ”what's the big dealio”. But, the dangers of loose rock, exposure, bad weather, route finding, et.al. still exist and challenge even the most experienced mountaineer. Guess that's part of the allure of it all. Congrats to all on the summits. Happy trails!


Kevin Baker


Nice     2010-07-27 09:22:39
Awesome report as always, Otina. That buttress route looks worse than the north couloir! I think the rock is looser in the couloir, but way less exposed. So it looks like you guys are lined up to finish this year, maybe on Longs? That would be a great one to finish on!


Jon Frohlich


Glad we didn't do that...     2010-07-27 13:05:35
After seeing this I think that the route we did sticking to the rocks on the right side of the normal gully is better than this. It was loose and not something I'd want to descend but nothing compared to what those slabs look like. My opinion might have changed had we not been the only two on the route that morning though.


bergsteigen


Thanks!     2010-07-27 14:35:59
Nelson - It's a Canon S90 with a polarizing filter attachment. The camera allows me easy manual control, and so I can do much better than the standard P&S

Keith - You very well may have saved our lives as well. The couple minute delay on entering the slabs was key! Quite glad you stuck to it on Sunday and got Wilson as well.

britdog, doggler, Jon - That buttress route held so much promise that morning! I bet if there wasn't the group above, ”trying” to kill us, then my perspective would be different. Loose but tolerable with a competent group. The route from Kilpacker should be the only way to do those two. But as we needed Wilson P, and we couldn't pull off the trifecta, Navaho lake seemed logical. Maybe a basecamp move mid trip, would be the best option.

Kevin - I am seeing a finisher on Longs in the near future, should everything go well the next couple weeks


d_baker


it's all relative sometimes     2010-07-27 16:37:40
Interesting take on the N Buttress route. Our trip last fall was uneventful and mostly solid rock. In fact, I recommended this route in my TR!
We went to the right like Keith did near the top, but were probably on class 4/exposed ledges. Rock was good though.
Nice report and pictures team!


MtnHigh


North Buttress     2010-08-04 14:33:33
Wish I had taken a closer look at this TR before last weekend. I got to the top of the Arete, saw it go from solid to skinny & exposed, and decided to back off and down. Of course, the monsoon weather already moving in at 9:30am helped with the decision, as did memories of a previous Wilson-El Diente traverse in 2001 and getting pretty rattled by the exposure. Nice TR!



   Using your forum id/password. Not registered? Click Here


Caution: The information contained in this report may not be accurate and should not be the only resource used in preparation for your climb. Failure to have the necessary experience, physical conditioning, supplies or equipment can result in injury or death. 14ers.com and the author(s) of this report provide no warranties, either express or implied, that the information provided is accurate or reliable. By using the information provided, you agree to indemnify and hold harmless 14ers.com and the report author(s) with respect to any claims and demands against them, including any attorney fees and expenses. Please read the 14ers.com Safety and Disclaimer pages for more information.

© 2014 14ers.com®, 14ers Inc.