Peak(s):  Pettingell Pk  -  13,553 feet
Date Posted:  10/21/2009
Date Climbed:   10/17/2009
Author:  Greenhouseguy
 A Grand Day on the Divide  

Pettingell Peak
13,553 Feet (Ranked 217th in CO)
Southeast Slopes from Herman Gulch Trailhead (10,250 Feet)
Class 2
October 17th, 2009
8.9 Miles Roundtrip
Elevation Gained: Approximately 3,400 Feet
Greenhouseguy (Brian) and Jason (JasonF)

A Grand Day on the Divide

Pettingell Peak was named for pioneer Jacob N. Pettingell, who came to Colorado from Boston in 1880. Pettingell was one of the most prominent early residents of Grand Lake, where he served the public as a postmaster, county commissioner, and county court judge. Having the highest point in Grand County named after him is a fitting tribute to his more than 50 years of public service in the county.


(L to R) "The Citadel," Unnamed Pt. 13,418, and Pettingell Peak seen from Mt. Machebeuf (image taken 11/1/08)

Of the several routes that are used to access Pettingell Peak, the Herman Gulch approach is certainly the most popular. Pettingell just barely falls short of being a Bicentennial peak, but the Herman Gulch Trail is a Centennial wildflower trail with more than 100 colorful varieties of native plants during the height of the season. The plentiful wildflowers and the alpine lake (Herman Lake) at the top of the gulch bring plenty of hikers to the Herman Gulch trail; oddly, Pettingell Peak sees relatively few hikers.


The Herman Gulch Trailhead

It looked like Pettingell Peak was going to be a solo hike for me, but I had the good fortune to run into member Jason (JasonF) at the trailhead. We geared up and hit the trail in a matter of minutes. I had worn some of my warmest gear in anticipation of much colder temperatures; I was almost disappointed by the mild weather. The lower part of the trail was entirely snow-free. After 0.2 miles, we bore to the left at the junction with the Bard Creek Trail


Snow-free conditions on the lower portion of the Herman Gulch Trail

We hiked under a canopy of pines and aspens for a while until we came to the first of several broad meadows. In late July, this meadow is a choice spot to find our state flower, the Rocky Mountain Columbine. In mid-October, the distant Pettingell Peak provides the best scenery.


Looking up Herman Gulch towards Pettingell Peak

As we progressed up the gulch, we had Mt. Machebeuf to the right and Mt. Bethel to the left. Mt. Bethel is the peak that has two parallel snow fences on the side that faces I-70; these fences keep snow from accumulating in the avalanche chute above the highway. A pair of backcountry skiers nearly died in an avalanche on Mt. Machebeuf back in 2004; under extreme conditions, an avalanche could potentially reach the Herman Gulch Trail. At about the 2.75-mile mark, we reached the junction with the Continental Divide Trail that heads over towards Jones Pass.


Junction with the Continental Divide Trail

After another quarter mile and a few switchbacks, we finally reached Herman Lake. The last section of trail before the lake is pretty steep, so the lake was a natural spot to take a break and plan our next moves. The scenery at the lake is fantastic, with Pettingell Peak to the northwest and "The Citadel" to the southwest.


A view of "The Citadel" from Herman Lake

On the north side of the lake, an obvious ramp leads to the saddle between Pt. 13,418 and Pettingell Peak. This should be easy, right? The snow on the lake's shore was unpredictable; it was ankle-deep in some spots, and knee-deep in others. We both had waterproof boots and gaiters, so it didn't really matter as long as we didn't snap an ankle postholing in the talus. The real work began when we started up a gully that led to the ramp on the north side of the lake.


The ramp on the north side of Herman Lake that leads to the saddle between Pt. 13,418 and Pettingell Peak

A couple of stone cairns in the gully let us know that we had started out in the right direction. The snow was deep enough to be an issue, so we stayed on exposed rocks as much as possible.


Heading up the gully above Herman Lake

Instead of following the ramp up to the saddle, we tried a more direct route towards the summit. Progress slowed to a crawl on the exceptionally steep talus.


Jason on steep talus higher in the gully

The route only got steeper as we struggled in the jumble of rocks on the right hand side of the gully. The grade of the slope would not have been a problem if the talus had been stable; however, the rocks were perched on an unstable base. We would take one step forward, and slide half a step backwards.


Jason on an annoyingly loose section of rock

We finally approached Class 3 territory below Pettingell's east ridge. The rock, which was barely stable enough to stand on, was also too rotten to climb on. I broke several handholds loose, and we both sent several large rocks cartwheeling down the slope. We gradually moved to the left (west) where the rock was far more stable.


Jason picking his way through the junk


Looking down our route towards Herman Lake. It would have been much easier to follow the snow/talus ramp that can be seen just above the lake in this image.


Jason making up for lost time on the easier terrain below the east ridge

I finally topped out on the east ridge a short distance from the summit. A minor bump on the ridge was the only obstacle that stood in my way.


Looking at the summit from the east ridge

It occurred to me on the summit that we had really beaten the weather report. It was sunny, reasonably warm, and hardly a breath of wind. This was atypical for the Continental Divide in October, but I didn't complain.


On the summit with McClellan/Torreys/Grays on my left and the Evans massif on my right

Several mountains (Mt. Machebeuf, Woods Mountain, Mt. Parnassus, Bard Peak, Robeson Peak, and Engelmann Peak) were directly to the east of Pettingell Peak. These peaks all have some degree of mountaineering interest.


Cluster of mountains east of Pettingell Peak

To the southeast, I could see down Herman Gulch all the way to I-70. I tried to scope out the best route on Mt. Bethel, but it looked steep from every direction. That's a good hike for another day.


The view down Herman Gulch

Our arduous ascent motivated me to find an easier way back to the lake. Why not try the standard route? The descent to the saddle between Pettingell and Pt. 13,418 was quick and easy. There was a steep hundred-foot snowfield below the saddle; we heel plunged and boot skied our way to the bottom. Jason caught a short glissade, which I presume was intentional! It appeared that the remainder of the route would be talus and grassy tundra interspersed with patchy snow.


The first part of the route just below the saddle

We followed the grassy ramp downward towards the lake. There were a few small cairns along the way, and some short stretches of faint trail. The drop-off on the edge of the ramp was significant.


Looking over the edge of the ramp at the frozen Herman Lake

Near the bottom of the grassy ramp, we rejoined our "gully route" from earlier in the day. We stayed on the edge of a big snowfield to avoid postholing in the deep snow in the center. Much of the snow in the gully had melted, leaving slick mud in its wake. Despite my best efforts, I managed to do a pretty good butt plant in the mud.


One last snowfield...

Beyond the lake, it was solid Class 1 trail and smooth sailing for the three miles back to the trailhead. The fantastic fall weather had drawn hikers to the trail like a magnet; we passed dozens of people on the way back down. It's a pretty tame trail, and I just wanted to put it behind me and get back to the car. It turned out to be a pretty good day; I met a new hiking partner, I visited a pretty decent summit, and I enjoyed a beautiful fall day outdoors. And it cost me less than a quarter tank of gas!


Heading down the trail on the way back to the parking lot


GPS track of our hike

Thumbnails for uploaded photos (click to open slideshow):
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23

 Comments or Questions

10/21/2009 12:47
It looks like you captured the ever elusive Sasquatch in picture #13 !


Great report
10/21/2009 13:15
what a slog that upper portion above the lake was - if I didn‘t like scrambling so much I‘d have definitely opted for staying low and to the left (like we went down). Thanks for the great hike!!

mtgirl - I‘ve been called many things but that description may take the cake. I‘m sure my wife probably thinks I smell like sasquatch after getting back home from the hikes


Sorry JasonF !
10/21/2009 15:36

I meant you no insult........but seeing that black blur running thru the talus in Photo #13 reminded me of those old Sasquatch reportings......


Great Report, Sasquatch!
10/21/2009 15:56
Pettingell always is a fun scramble. I think MtnGirl is right on, though... You might just get your own TV show....

   Using your forum id/password. Not registered? Click Here

Caution: The information contained in this report may not be accurate and should not be the only resource used in preparation for your climb. Failure to have the necessary experience, physical conditioning, supplies or equipment can result in injury or death. and the author(s) of this report provide no warranties, either express or implied, that the information provided is accurate or reliable. By using the information provided, you agree to indemnify and hold harmless and the report author(s) with respect to any claims and demands against them, including any attorney fees and expenses. Please read the Safety and Disclaimer pages for more information.

© 2020®, 14ers Inc.