Peak(s):  Hagerman Peak  -  13,841 feet
Date Posted:  09/13/2022
Modified:  09/14/2022
Date Climbed:   09/11/2022
Author:  5ClimbingCooneys
 Hagerman peak via Roach 20.A1V high route   

For anyone looking about information regarding Gerry Roach's 20.A1V route listed in his book, Colorado Thirteeners this trip report contains beta about that approach.

----------------------------------------------------------------

First off, I'd like to climb on a little soap box for a moment and reach out to anyone driving 4x4 roads in Colorado, especially to the climbing community driving these 4x4 trails. With the increase in traffic most peaks are seeing, I've seen a huge increase in people on these 4x4 roads, which are quickly eroding and becoming more difficult and also attracting more dedicated off-road enthusiasts. This results in vehicles and people of different capabilities being on the roads at the same time and needing to coexist peacefully. Lately, I've been having more run-ins with road users lacking basic courtesy. In Colorado, I've heard the adage that "uphill traffic has the right of way" repeated endlessly. This isn't entirely accurate, and I think this community could help spread the word about how the law is actually worded. Colorado Revised Statutes Title 42: Vehicles and Traffic § 42-4-711. Driving on mountain highways states:

"On narrow mountain highways with turnouts having a grade of six percent or more, ascending vehicles shall have the right-of-way over descending vehicles, except where it is more practicable for the ascending vehicle to return to a turnout."

That last portion is key: "except where it is more practicable for the ascending vehicle to return to a turnout." I've been placed in several dangerous situations because people will keep driving right at me uphill without stopping, even if they have an obvious pullout only feet away. I assume they're doing so because they believe they have the ironclad right of way. That is not true!! If you're forcing the downhill traveling vehicle to reverse up dangerous terrain, or there is no nearby pullout available for them, the uphill-traveling traffic still has some obligation to try to pull over as well. This happened twice on my trip up & down the Lost Trail Creek road. The last guy was driving a well-equipped blue Jeep Renegade and all he had to do was back down 30 feet on a level road to a wide pullout, but he refused to even look, insisting I had to back up no matter what, which forced me on the side of one of the erosion control berms with a tire hanging over into the creek and barely enough room for him to safely pass.

----------------------------------------------------------------

A couple quick notes about the "upper" Lost Trail Creek road into Lead King Basin:

  1. The road is rocky & rough from it's start up until about the avalanche area. Rocks ranged in size from baseballs to cantaloupes with the occasional watermelon size tire-popper in the way that were generally avoidable. They were not soft, squishy, and round though!
  2. The avalanche area is no longer of any concern.
  3. After the avalanche area (and a little before) the road is surprisingly smooth for a Colorado mountain 4x4 road. It's very steep, narrow, and covered in lots of loose dirt though, so 4x4 is still very much needed.
  4. Because there are so few rocks, the upper switchbacks would be a harrowing ordeal if sloppy and wet. Don't try it after a good monsoon rain.
  5. The road has a copious amount of large erosion control berms. Even in a short wheelbase high clearance SUV I found myself dragging the empty tow hitch on a few of these. Luckily they're just dirt. Trucks of any kind will probably do the same and have some "fun" negotiating the switchbacks due to how tight they are.
  6. I did not see a Subaru. Maybe that's saying something...?


The "High Route" Approach to Geneva Lake

I woke up in the morning and found I was coming down with a decent cold, so I half-heartedly decided that since I'd spent the effort to drive up there, I might as well not let the day be a complete waste. I set out to explore Roach's old variation to Geneva Lake and see if it would work to bring my wife back that way on a later trip to climb Snowmass. I'd spent a while before the trip looking at Google Earth and could see at least some remnants of an old trail on satellite view. The trail looked strong enough that if I could find it, I was reasonably sure it would go all the way to the lake. The trick would be finding it. It doesn't really become visible until it crosses some of the grassy slopes higher up on Meadow mountain above some prominent gray gullies (approximately 39.086831, -107.095950). I knew if I missed the trail, the traverse over would be problematic since the terrain becomes incredibly steep in places. Luckily, the trail is there and it goes pretty well once you're on it. Using satellite view on Google Earth, I traced the trail and made a map in CalTopo. (I don't hike with a GPS, so any coordinates given are pulled from Google and weren't collected on location).

To start Roach's high route variation to Geneva lake, I parked at a large pullout just below 10,800' shortly after the "trailhead" for the Silver Creek Pass (approximate coordinates of 39.078526, -107.102475). There' enough room for 3-4 vehicles to park here, or a small party to camp. The road Roach mentions to start the hike on is marked as private and I didn't see any other boundary markings, so I headed northeast directly up the forested slope aiming for a clearing starting around 11,000' (approximate coordinates: 39.079253, -107.100760; if anyone has info about where the property boundary is here please let me know so I can revise the map and update this report). Once out of the forrest, the foliage up here was thick and very tall! In September, the plants were waist to chest high and it made the next 0.75 of a mile slower going that I would have liked.

From the clearing, I contoured over as best I could without gaining unneeded elevation into the next drainage east of Silver Creek coming off of Meadow Mountain above. My goal was to more or less maintain my elevation around 11,000' without getting too high, knowing that I'd need to cross the drainage before finding the trail. I bushwhacked through the large clearing, weaving around a few clumps of trees until I was in the drainage, then spotted something of game trail leading up around one of the clusters of pines on the opposite side of the small creek. I followed this, but it quickly petered out on the grassy slopes above, so I set off NNE up the broad grassy ridge hoping I'd intersect the trail. As I continued gradually up the slope, I noticed what looked like post or dead tree stump above the last pines on the broad, grassy ridge at about 11,200'. I made my way over there and saw it was indeed a human-placed post and found the trail about 10' above. Vundebar! (approximate coordinates: 39.086837, -107.096341).

From the post, the trail more or less stays right around 11,200' as it contours above several prominent gray gullies and crosses the upper portions of two avalanche chutes on the SSE slopes of Meadow Mountain. After about 0.25 mile, the trail passes through some trees, then begins to switchback down about 200' to pass below a small band of cliffs. A few of the switchbacks were easy lose, but it wasn't difficult to guess where the trail was leading, so it was pretty easy to get back on route if I found myself going too far past one of the corners. (I believe there were 10 total switchbacks).

After the switchbacks, the trail crosses the relatively prominent gully below the cliffs and traverses across some very steep terrain around the 10,900' - 11,000' foot level. In several places here the trail was quite narrow with extremely steep slopes dropping away below. I would not want to hike this section if it was wet or snowy and it would be nearly impossible to cross this area of the mountain without the trail. The slopes are covered in small aspens and thick vegetation at an impossible angle and without the trail you'd be grabbing at branches to keep on your feet.

Past this section, the trail briefly heads uphill in a more northerly direction into a small flat area with a few willows. It's easy to lose the trail here, but it you do, you're close to the Geneva Lake trail, which is just a little below in elevation and to the east. The trail intersects the Geneva Lake trail at about 10,960' and is marked with an old primitive post (see photo later on).

Overall, following the trail proved to be a mostly easy task and was definitely faster than wading through the chest-high labyrinth of grass and foliage encountered on the first 0.75 mile. The trail is definitely disappearing and thin in many areas, but with a sharp eye, if you know where it should be, it's not too difficult to keep track of. In some of the more grassy areas I suspect it's only a matter of a few years before it's completely overgrown unless the deer and elk frequent it or it gathers a little more use. Because of the thick vegetation for the first half of the approach and the accumulation of small elevation changes, it's probably less effort to just drive to the main trailhead and start there. This is especially true on the return trip when it would take far less effort to just plod downhill on the Geneva trail instead of traversing the additional distance AND gaining about an extra 300' in elevation on the return. Based on my Google measurements, the high route adds a bit more mileage and elevation than Roach's book indicates. I came up with a round trip mileage of 4.25 miles and around 800' of elevation gain (~500' on the way to the lake; ~300' on the return) vs about 3.5 miles and 1,300' of gain (all on the way up to the lake) for the traditional approach up the Geneva Lake trail. The upper route essentially adds 0.75 miles and saves about 500' at the cost of some slower moving terrain. If hiking this in the morning after a nice dew has settled or after a rain, the first portion of the hike would be miserably wet. The second portion (on the primitive trail), if wet, would be outright dangerous. However, there was lots of wildlife to see up here and if you're up for a bit more of an adventure, or the parking is full at the main trailhead and you're a confident, competent route finder, this route is a viable alternative.


On up to Hagerman....

I still wasn't feeling 100%, but I wasn't feeling outright lousy, so I decided to keep plodding along at a reduced pace for as long as my body would tolerate it. I didn't feel like any more bushwhacking and the area around the lake was covered in a thick coat of frost—making wading off-trail through more foliage downright unappealing—so I opted to follow the Trail Rider pass trail along the northern edge of the lake and around the south ridge of Hagerman to the standard south slopes route instead of trying for one of the couloirs leading up the south ridge or shortcutting the Trail Rider Pass trail by bushwhacking across the creek below the lake and up the forested hill on the other side. There's no sign indicating where the trail for Trail Rider Pass splits off from the trail going further up the valley, but if you follow what looks like the "main" and not any of the side trails to various campsites, it'll lead you there anyway. Crossing the creek would probably involve some wading well into July, but in mid-September is was easy to hop across on a few small rocks. Once across, I bashed through some obligatory frozen willows along the trail and followed the comparatively nice, easy Trail Rider path on up the starting point for the Hagerman south slopes route.

In my research, there seemed to be a LOT of information directed at finding some obscure path through the willows once you leave the Trail Rider Pass path and not getting confused regarding which gully to use on the approach. This is all overkill; it's really pretty simple. At about 11,500' the Trail Rider path leaves the drainage coming off of Hagerman/Snowmass Peak and makes a long switchback almost due south as it climbs steeply uphill. This is obviously not the way to Hagerman, so just leave the trail around the switchback and there's all sorts of room to avoid the willows. If you've come from Geneva Lake, this switchback is a bit past a signed intersection just above 11,400'. (Just before this intersection there's a path branching off into the willows toward Hagerman that has several stones piled up blocking it. Based on a few descriptions, I thought this might be fabled passage through the willows. Do not take it. Just follow the main trail until the switchback). At the switchback, there's a smaller somewhat grassy-looking gully more to your left and the main watercourse/gully that veers more to the right. The one to the left is route outlined here on 14ers.com and seemed more direct, so I went up that. The gully would present a few obstacles if there was water in it, but it was dry this late in the year, so it was pretty easy going on to the grassy bench before the ascending traverse to the rock gully.

21904_06
Showing the departure point from Trail Rider Pass. I took the left gully (same as the 14ers.com route).

There's not too much to say about the route past there. I ran into a couple of guys who indicated one member of their party was climbing in the gully, so I strapped on my helmet and slowly scampered on over that direction. While it looks somewhat cliffy below the couloir, there are ample breaks in the minor cliff bands and they presented no particular difficulty to get up through—just some fun (avoidable) scrambling. Once in the main gully, I found the terrain closer to the east "ridge" to be the most stable, so I more or less just picked my way up the next 1,000' of rubble-fest until I gained the summit ridge.

21904_01
Showing the remains route up Hagerman. Just follow the tundra then slog up through the rock. Stay right (more or less).

The ridge definitely has some awe-inspiring drops on the north side looking down into Snowmass Lake, but aside from the exposure on the ridge proper (which can be avoided), it was just a quick, fun scamper up to the summit. I met up with Dan, who was visiting from Houston and chatted with him for a bit before enjoying a nice lunch break solo on the summit. I took a few minutes to admire the ridge over to Snowmass. At one point, in the comfort of my home office, I was seriously considering taking a crack at that traverse with my wife in an effort to save a trip and link both summits. Seeing it in person, I'm reminded how easy it is to underestimate that kind of stuff. The exposure for the first ½ looked far worse in real life than anything online can convey. Combined with the crappy nature of the rock, I stand in admiration of those who have done it. It must take nerves of steel. Mine are apparently made of a softer material.

21904_05

21904_04
Looking back at Lead King Basin and the terrain the high route traversed earlier that morning (to the right).
21904_02
Looking back down the ascent route. The 14ers.com route (and my path) comes up through the grassy saddle in the middle of the photo.


21904_03
Kudos to anyone traversing this ridge!

The way down was uneventful. I passed Dan part way down and we arranged to stay on opposite sides of the couloir to avoid any potential rockfall issues. I needn't have worried anyway. For as loose as the rock was, I marveled at how quietly Dan descended. He may not have been the fastest man I've met, but he was definitely the most light-footed! Not so much as a single pebble seemed to move underfoot and he barely made a single noise the entire 1,000' descent down the couloir. From there it was lots of trail plodding back to the high route intersection.

21904_07
Showing the turn-off for the high route a short distance below Geneva Lake.
21904_08
Chest high foliage once off of the old trail wading across the meadow. Anyone need wildflower seeds?

At that point, I wish I would have just driven back to the trailhead as the mental and physical fatigue were starting to get to me far more than usual. Nonetheless, the route went easily enough and I found myself back at the car a disappointing 9 hours after I'd started. For climbing a peak the week before where I covered nearly 7 miles and over 3K vertical in under 4 hours round trip, I was disappointed to have to slow myself so much due to my cold. But, at least I got another Centennial. Only 12 more left now, which is exactly the same number I had left at the end of last season after climbing three new Centennials this year. Curses, LiDAR!!





Thumbnails for uploaded photos (click to open slideshow):
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


Comments or Questions
BillMiddlebrook
User
Cool!
09/14/2022 11:55
Shaun, this is great information and very interesting to see something so different. Thanks so much for posting!


5ClimbingCooneys
User
Long time!
09/14/2022 14:12
Thanks, Bill! It was nice to get back up there. Last time I was in that area is when I met you hiking down from Snowmass Mountain around 20 years ago. I remember you talking about a new website you were making and taking photos for the Snowmass route. It's nice to see how much your idea has taken off!


fepic1
User
Trail etiquette
09/16/2022 04:23
Thank you for the explanation of what I always thought was a unwritten rule. Uphill traffic has the right of way. Except where it is more practicable for the ascending vehicle to return to a turnout." I love the reference to the the Colorado revised statute title 42. : ) I always apply the same when hiking on the trail.
I did this same route in the spring as a snow climb it was amazing.
The barbecue restaurant in Marble is areal treat also.



   Not registered?


Caution: The information contained in this report may not be accurate and should not be the only resource used in preparation for your climb. Failure to have the necessary experience, physical conditioning, supplies or equipment can result in injury or death. 14ers.com and the author(s) of this report provide no warranties, either express or implied, that the information provided is accurate or reliable. By using the information provided, you agree to indemnify and hold harmless 14ers.com and the report author(s) with respect to any claims and demands against them, including any attorney fees and expenses. Please read the 14ers.com Safety and Disclaimer pages for more information.

Please respect private property: 14ers.com supports the rights of private landowners to determine how and by whom their land will be used. In Colorado, it is your responsibility to determine if land is private and to obtain the appropriate permission before entering the property.

© 2022 14ers.com®, 14ers Inc.