WARNING! It may be Quandary Peak, but this route is no joke. It requires plenty of time, good weather, supplies and solid Class 3 climbing skills. Once you get on the Class 3 section, retreat is difficult and people have gotten lost or put themselves in serious danger trying to exit before the summit.
From the dam area, Quandary is to the north but the west ridge is not visible. Taken from North Star Mountain, Photo #1 is a high-angle view of Quandary and the route leaving the dam. Climb up to the dam and drop down from the right side to find a trail. There are a couple of small trails that lead up from the lake but your goal is to climb briefly to a larger trail that heads west toward the basin. Photo #2 shows some of the trail. Once you reach the main trail, traverse west across the slope. Near 12,100‘, the trail angles northwest as it leads to the basin. Continue to the center of the basin near some mine remnants. From here, Photo #3 shows much of the basin and the remaining hike to reach the west ridge.
Taken near 12,300‘, Photo #4 shows the view ahead. Continue north through the basin on a trail along a stream and locate a gully to the northwest - Photo #5. Climb the left side of the gully, turn right and continue north on talus toward the end of the basin - Photo #6. Quandary‘s west ridge is up to your right, but avoid the temptation to climb directly to the ridge. Stay on the left side of the basin and, near 13,100‘, turn left (west) to exit the basin by ascending rock slabs and possibly some snow fields. Near 13,300‘, turn right (Photo #7) and traverse across a bump to gain the west ridge, just below 13,400‘.
Begin hiking east, on or along the ridge crest - Photo #8. Photo #9 and Photo #10 are views of the ridge, taken from Fletcher Mountain. Below 13,600‘, easiest passage is mostly on the right side of the ridge - Photo #11. Continue past several bumps and the ridge starts to steepen - Photo #12. Near 13,800‘, turn left and follow a trail (Photo #13) which ascends left, away from the ridge but eventually regains the ridge, near 14,000‘. Once back on the ridge, scramble over or around some bumps (Photo #14 and Photo #15) and continue along the ridge to a large point which has a steep, dirt gully. Drop into a notch and climb the dirt gully (Photo #16) to regain the ridge crest.
Continue scrambling along the ridge to reach a small wall with a vertical crack - Photo #17. Drop a bit and climb Class 3 rock near the crack. Once back on the ridge crest, the crux of the route soon comes into view - a wall which blocks easy passage to the summit - Photo #18. First, downclimb the south (right) side of the ridge near some white rock and then turn left to reach the base of the wall. The easiest way up is to climb the center of the wall, as seen in Photo #18. The lower portion is fairly straightforward, but you‘re soon faced with steep rock and no easy way through. Pick your line and regain the ridge. Taken from the top of the crux, Photo #19 looks back along the ridge. The show is over - continue 0.1 mile over to the summit - Photo #20.